Rothbury vs. Bonnaroo - A look back
Saturday, July 19th, 2008I’m finally unwinding from my July 4th weekend (yes, two weeks later) and got some free time to write up a bit about Rothbury.
For those of you who don’t know much about me, I have attended music festivals (the kind that draw hippies from around the country to camp out for 3 or 4 nights and listen to 20+ bands in a weekend) since I was in college. I was a bit obsessed with them, so after college I went and worked for a short time with a promoter on the east coast. It was a blast, and quite revealing on the back-end of the scene.
When that company eventually ceased to operate, I found myself back as an attendee at music festivals, rather then behind the scenes. That was the first year that Bonnaroo happened - a music festival in Manchester, TN that, with no formal advertising campaign, sold out 50,000+ tickets in just a few weeks at $100+ a pop. Three stages of music over four days (and a few beers later), I was hooked. Music festivals were clearly the next big “music industry thing.” For me, anyway.
From 2002 to 2007 I have been to every Bonnaroo and have watched the festival evolve. Each year I have gone with the hope that the festival would grow and learn more - new art, new logistics for the festival itself, better services, different music. Bonnaroo met that challenge for the first few years. To add to it, I always challenged myself to try something new - car camping, RVing, VIP, no car (tent-only) camping, no tent camping (yikes - thanks United Airlines for losing my bags!), etc. This just added to the fun and experience. I learned a ton about how to be a great festival go-er.
Skip to 2007, and a host of music festivals now dot the country of this magnitude. 10,000 Lakes Music Festival, Langerado, All Good Music Festival, Vegoose, and so on - just to name a few. Each one of these has taken a page from the other, and it seems like they each try and “one up” each other from year to year.
Then came 2008. While I had noticed a distinct shift in direction (and type of attendees) at Bonnaroo since 2002, the lineup was always interesting. I bought my flight and reserved transportation in November - before the lineup was even announced. But this year, when I heard Metallica was the headliner, with Kayne West. This was a big letdown for me - Bonnaroo’s first ever - to the point where I actually decided to cancel my ticket and plans to go.
Then Rothbury was announced.
The line-up was just like Bonnaroo 2002, and the location looked better. My hopes were high, so high, that I worried they wouldn’t be met. After all my experience I certainly had some standards to meet.
Well, I’m pleased to announce that ROTHBURY BLEW ME AWAY. The festival was fantastic. It felt like someone had gone around and looked at every annoying detail about every festival and fixed it. Everything was better - from no lines to get in, to lots of room to park and camp, to lots of space on the concert fields, to the amazing sherwood forest and the related psychedellic light show there, to the calm and relaxing get-away at the beach, to the cabins that dotted the property - even the wristbands they issued were comfortable! It seemed like everything was so smoothly setup and run, I just couldn’t believe it.
Rothbury has won me over, but it’s also showed me that you can clearly keep raising the bar - it just takes some new creativity. It is my sincere hope that Rothbury does not get so excited about this year’s success that they try to “blow up” the place with too many people and not enough new creativity. That is where, looking back, I felt like Bonnaroo fell short. It wasn’t so much the line-up that disappointed me, but the fact that nothing on the festival grounds has really changed in the last three years, so a crummy lineup + no new festival grounds “stuff” wasn’t a compelling enough reason to drop ~$2,000 for the trip there (I’m coming from California, so it ends up costing!).
Anyway, check out the photos I’ll be posting tomorrow for some awesome Rothbury pics.
and here’s to a Phish reunion

